Understanding the US national debt
Raymond James Chief Economist Eugenio Alemán and Economist Giampiero Fuentes examine nation's growing debt burden
The national debt is often treated as a political scorecard, but the central challenge has to do less with the United States’ ability to pay than with the political system’s willingness to put its fiscal account on a sustainable path.
Federal debt ownership
First, we need to separate gross federal debt from debt held by the public. Gross debt includes Treasury securities held within the federal government, particularly in trust funds such as Social Security. These are assets to one government account and liabilities to another, so they do not directly represent financing raised from outside the federal government.
Debt held by the public, by contrast, is owned by outside investors, including households, funds, banks, insurers, the Federal Reserve and foreign investors, and is the more economically relevant measure. This debt must be financed in capital markets, requiring the government to continually attract investors and make interest payments. As it grows, it can increase borrowing costs, consume a larger share of federal tax revenues and potentially compete with private investment for capital.
Today, net interest payments on the federal debt exceed $1 trillion annually, more than four times the roughly $240 billion paid just a decade ago. Who owns the debt matters, but the cost of financing it matters more. The US relies on a broad mix of investors to buy Treasury securities and refinance debt as it comes due. As long as there is strong demand for Treasuries, the government can continue to borrow and refinance its obligations.
The bigger concern is what happens when interest rates rise, because refinancing becomes more expensive and interest payments take up more of the federal budget. For investors, the key things to watch are the ability and the willingness of the US government to commit the resources necessary to pay the interest on the debt.
When national debt becomes a concern
There is no universally accepted dollar total or debt-to-GDP ratio that automatically triggers a crisis. A large economy with deep markets, its own currency and strong demand for its bonds can support more debt than a smaller, less credible borrower. The nominal debt total alone is therefore an incomplete signal.
A better question is whether the burden is becoming harder to service relative to the economy and federal revenue, and persistent primary deficits (the deficit without including interest payments on the debt) require borrowing not only to refinance old debt, but also to fund ongoing operations.
A debt ratio near 100% of GDP is not a precise cliff; it signals a smaller margin for error. A recession, war, financial crisis, pandemic or rate shock can add to an already elevated fiscal deficit, which adds to an already elevated base. Higher interest costs can create a loop: more borrowing increases debt, raises future interest expense and requires still more borrowing.
The level of debt becomes a problem when the cost of servicing it requires fiscal adjustments large enough to meaningfully weaken the economy. For example, if the government must raise taxes, or increase tax revenues by improving tax collections, or reduce spending so aggressively to meet rising interest costs, it could push the economy into recession, and a vicious cycle could emerge: weaker growth reduces tax revenues, increases fiscal pressures and makes the debt burden even harder to stabilize. The key distinction is between the ability and willingness to pay. Because the United States borrows in its own currency, it avoids a common source of sovereign default risk: owing debt in a foreign currency while collecting taxes in US dollars.
The US also has another important advantage: compared with many other developed economies, it has greater capacity to raise additional revenue through higher taxes or just by collecting those taxes that have not been collected for lack of resources, if needed. However, higher taxes and/or higher tax collection are sometimes bad for elections, and politicians are typically unwilling to do what is needed. The challenge is whether the political system is willing to make the necessary choices, through higher tax revenues, slower spending growth or some combination, to put the debt on a sustainable path.
Debt sustainability is the realistic goal
The United States could meaningfully improve its debt situation through one or a combination of the following: sustained primary surpluses, stronger growth, slower spending growth, higher tax revenues, higher taxes and/or lower financing costs. Completely eliminating the debt is theoretically possible, but neither necessary nor clearly desirable. However, the more realistic goal is sustainability: stabilize publicly held debt relative to GDP by slowing down the growth in government expenditures and/or collecting more taxes and then allow the economy to grow faster than the growth in the debt so the debt comes down as a percentage of GDP.
Achieving that goal will require difficult choices and trade-offs. Slower government spending growth and higher tax revenues can improve the fiscal outlook, but they may also weigh on economic activity and gains in economic well-being, particularly if implemented too aggressively. The good news is that there is room to increase federal tax revenues as a share of GDP, particularly relative to many other developed economies.
For investors, the national debt is not a bill that must someday be paid in full, but a continuing financing obligation that must remain credible and affordable. The goal is not to eliminate the debt, but to keep it from growing faster than the country’s capacity to support it.
All expressions of opinion reflect the judgment of the author(s) and the Investment Strategy Committee and are subject to change. This information should not be construed as a recommendation. The foregoing content is subject to change at any time without notice. Content provided herein is for informational purposes only. There is no guarantee that these statements, opinions or forecasts provided herein will prove to be correct. Past performance is not a guarantee of future results. Indices and peer groups are not available for direct investment. Any investor who attempts to mimic the performance of an index or peer group would incur fees and expenses that would reduce returns. No investment strategy can guarantee success. Economic and market conditions are subject to change. Investing involves risks including the possible loss of capital. The information has been obtained from sources considered to be reliable, but we do not guarantee that the foregoing material is accurate or complete. Diversification and asset allocation do not ensure a profit or protect against a loss.
